Welcome to Hearthstone Oven
Hearthstone Oven is a charming eatery located in Ithaca, MI, known for its delightful homestyle cooking and welcoming atmosphere. This Amish-owned establishment serves up mouthwatering breakfast and lunch options, including famous cinnamon and pecan rolls that keep patrons returning for more. Guests rave about the homemade bakery items, like freshly baked bread and casseroles, delivered with friendly service. The relaxed environment enhances the dining experience, making it a perfect stop for both casual meals and take-home delights. With fair prices and an extensive menu, Hearthstone Oven stands out as a hidden gem worth the visit.
-
126 S Pine River St, Ithaca, MI 48847, United States Hotline: +1 989-875-6836
Welcome to Hearthstone Oven, a delightful culinary gem nestled in the heart of Ithaca, Michigan. Located at 126 S Pine River St, this restaurant uniquely encompasses the essence of homestyle dining, where every meal feels like a warm embrace from your grandmother. Known for its delicious baked goods and hearty meals, Hearthstone Oven is not just a restaurant; it’s a community hub where flavors linger and memories are made.
With praise from local patrons filling the air, the restaurant boasts an impressive menu that features everything from cinnamon rolls and pecan rolls to savory frozen chicken pot pies. Reviewers like Georgia Lehman rave about the crave-worthy baked goods, highlighting the consistent quality that keeps customers coming back for more. In a world where fast dining has become the norm, Hearthstone Oven offers a refreshing return to the values of homemade culinary traditions.
The service here is frequently described as friendly and welcoming. Jason Miller appreciates the pleasant demeanor of the staff, even when they seem busy handling the bustling restaurant. It's a testament to the team's dedication, as they provide a personal touch to your dining experience. As you settle in, the muted yet clean atmosphere fosters a relaxing environment perfect for enjoying a meal with family or friends.
Richard West captures the sentiment well, calling Hearthstone Oven a “diamond in the rough.” The restaurant’s Amish roots shine through in the delightful array of food options. From homemade casseroles to freshly baked bread and cookies, variety is the spice of life here. The consistent quality of the food, as mentioned by Paul Birgy, makes it hard to resist trying everything on the menu—this is a place where indulgence is encouraged!
For those who appreciate breakfast and lunch options (note: they’re closed on Sundays), the menu features a range of hearty dishes. Tanya McHenry shares that on busy Saturday mornings, the wait for food is worth it, particularly for those crispy, savory bacon offerings that have drawn her back time and again.
Whether you're a local or passing through, getting to know Hearthstone Oven means discovering a culinary experience rooted in quality, hospitality, and delicious flavors. With the ability to pick up homemade frozen casseroles to take home, they cater to the needs of every busy home chef. So, next time your stomach grumbles or your sweet tooth beckons, consider making the drive to Hearthstone Oven—a place where every meal tells a story, and each bite is a celebration of good food and good company.
For inquiries, you can reach them at +1 989-875-6836.
The staff was friendly and helpful. Cinnamon rolls and pecan rolls are the best. Bread is great and the frozen chicken pot pie is delicious. That’s all we have had so far. We will be back
Food was amazing and when the server was at the table she was very pleasant, but they were either short-handed or busier than anticipated, because she had what appeared to be every table in the restaurant. The atmosphere is very muted, which makes sense, but was also very clean
Everything about this place is excellent, consistent and you will struggle with when to stop with the purchases. Just go there!!!
Delicious homestyle food, great service and good prices. There are so many tasty options on the menu. Homemade bakery goods at the counter, dinners packaged to go. You won't leave hungry. Open for breakfast and lunch, closed on Sundays. Fair prices and friendly staff.
Food was delicious. Love the option of purchasing homemade frozen casseroles, freshly baked bread and cookies! Service was slow, but still looking forward to coming back. Could be an isolated occurrence.
Went on the busiest day for them, a Saturday morning . Food is so worth the wait. The bacon is amazing! And the bakery is phenomenal. We are planning on going earlier next time, to get some of the bakery items that sold out before we could get them.
A lovely little spot with very friendly staff. The server, Brooke, was enthusiastic and the Hostess, Iva,was an absolute delight as well. Everything was delicious & I would definitely come back next visit to the area. The billboard coming into town directed me here, glad I listened to my gut (and my stomach)
This place is a diamond in the rough. Amish owned with delicious baked goods. All three servers were kind and modestly dressed. Food is affordable and delicious. Atmosphere is relaxing and peaceful. This is worth a drive out of the way to get here. I highly recommend this place. I wish there were more restaurants like this one.